Back

Best Umbrella Insurance Policies for 2021

by Jessie Jordan,  Jun 23 2021

Table of Contents

Best Umbrella Insurance Options by Category

Best for Competitive Premiums When Bundling: Allstate

Best for Business Owners: Chubb

Best for Small Business Liability Needs: Travelers

Best for Military-Associated Individuals: USAA

Best Overall: Liberty Mutual

Tips for Buying Umbrella Insurance 

Umbrella Insurance FAQs

Methodology

Umbrella insurance provides additional protection in cases where you might experience a major claim or loss, like an umbrella over all your other insurance policies. Homeowner and auto insurance policies cover liability for an accident or injury, but an umbrella policy extends coverage. 

Businesses and individuals benefit from umbrella insurance coverage because it can provide protection in the rare instance where an accident or claim runs into the hundreds of thousands of dollars or higher. Umbrella insurance can be especially important if you have significant assets that may make you the target of a lawsuit.

Best Umbrella Insurance Options

Here are some strong options for insurers with excellent reputations for high-quality customer service, dependable coverage, and affordable premiums. 

Best Umbrella Policy for Competitive Premiums When Bundling: Allstate

Allstate’s personal umbrella policies cover bodily injury, personal injury, and property damage. For example, if a guest has an accident in your backyard that results in high medical bills, a personal umbrella policy could help to cover high expenses. Allstate’s umbrella policies are available in million-dollar increments from $1 million to $5 million. The insurer’s reputation for affordable premiums is also stronger if you are buying other policies from them, including automobile, watercraft, and motorcycle insurance policies.

Pros:

  • Very inexpensive premiums for current and new Allstate customers 
  • Strong reputation for boat owner policies (boat accidents can be a big source of liability)

Cons:

  • Low coverage limits compared to what some small businesses need
  • Minimum coverage still needed on other policies first

Best Business Umbrella Insurance: Chubb

Finding the best umbrella insurance provider for a medium to large-size business can be trickier than finding an insurer for lower-limit personal policies. Chubb specializes in offering tailored solutions for U.S. and Canadian-based companies with coverage up to $25 million. It specifically works with companies that have extensive risk management programs and revenues greater than $1 billion, making them a valuable option if your business needs protection against catastrophic loss. 

Pros:

  • A wide variety of coverage options protect against lawsuits of many kinds
  • Strong track record of long-term contracts with major companies 

Cons:

  • Extensive process to get a quote 
  • May not fit small businesses with limited liability

Best for Small Business Liability Needs: Travelers

Travelers offers many options for those who need more coverage than the average personal policy. Coverage options branch out beyond the standard umbrella, including specialty Excess and Surplus insurance as well as monoline insurance, which can help if a single element was excluded from another small business insurance policy. Talk to a Travelers agent to get a small business umbrella quote and to learn how you can customize a policy to your needs.

Pros:

  • Customizable small business policies
  • Easy online quote process 

Cons:

  • May need to work with an agent to finalize an online quote 
  • Potentially higher prices if you have insurance from another insurer

Competitive Option for Military-Associated Individuals: USAA

Active duty military, veterans, and military spouses are often familiar with USAA, but it’s helpful to know they offer personal umbrella coverage. For about $1 a day in some cases, you will have peace of mind knowing that an accident won’t be devastating to your finances. Unless you already have reasonable insurance elsewhere that offers a compelling bundling discount, military families should consider USAA given the strength of the insurer and the affordability of its premiums. 

Pros:

  • Inexpensive add-on umbrella policy
  • Trustworthy company with strong financials

Cons:

  • Only for USAA members
  • No commercial umbrella insurance

Best Budget-Friendly Personal and Commercial Umbrella Insurance: Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual offers your standard auto insurance policy and homeowners policy. But it’s also a great fit if you want the same insurance company to underwrite a personal umbrella policy for extra coverage. The company also offers affordable options for umbrella insurance for businesses. 

Pros:

  • Multiple options for policy limits above $1 million
  • Coverage extends globally, a value-add if you travel

Cons:

  • Purchase process requires a potentially time-consuming agent call
  • Pricing can vary between current Liberty Mutual policyholders and those seeking umbrella policy as a standalone policy

Tips for Buying Umbrella Insurance 

It’s usually best to begin your umbrella insurance search with your current insurer, since many companies will charge a bundling discount if you add umbrella coverage to an existing policy. 

Determine how much coverage you want at the outset, since many umbrella insurance policies begin with $1 million in coverage and go up from there. Make sure to compare the level of coverage when looking at premium costs.

And lastly, be sure to discuss your personal situation with a qualified insurance agent. Many businesses use umbrella business insurance with higher limits because the potential for high-cost lawsuits is higher. On the other hand, a personal umbrella insurance policy may not need to cover more than your net worth.

Umbrella Insurance FAQs

Who has the best umbrella insurance policy?

We found excellent, competitive umbrella insurance options at Allstate, Chubb, Travelers, USAA, and Liberty Mutual. However, remember that your current insurer may offer a better deal by letting you bundle umbrella insurance with other policies. 

Can I buy umbrella insurance separately?

While it is usually cheaper and easier to get umbrella coverage from your primary insurer due to bundling discounts, some companies will sell you a separate umbrella insurance policy. This is most common, however, for businesses with large policy needs.

What is umbrella insurance?

This coverage extends your protection against liability claims, which can include anything from property damage to medical injury liability, libel or slander, and landlord liability. 

How does umbrella insurance work?

If a claim fits within the coverage limits of your homeowner’s insurance or auto insurance, you’re all set. If a claim exceeds those limits, umbrella insurance covers the difference.

Who needs umbrella insurance?

Generally, businesses and rental property owners should consider umbrella insurance, as well as individuals and families with a net worth of $1 million or more. 

How much does umbrella insurance cost?

According to the Insurance Information Institute, $1 million in umbrella coverage can cost as little as $150 and as much as $300 annually. Higher coverage tends to cost less— about $50-$75 per additional $1 million— since claims that large are rare.

Methodology

In choosing the best umbrella insurance options, we evaluated company credit ratings to evaluate their overall strength as a business. We consulted ratings as reported by A.M. Best, the Insurance Information Institute, and Kiplinger’s Umbrella Insurance Calculator. We also took into account customer satisfaction, availability, coverage limits, and costs for both personal and business umbrella policies, in addition to reviewing insurance company offerings. 

Editorial content on Gabi.com is reviewed by a licensed insurance agent. It is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal or financial advice.
Written by
Jessie Jordan
Jessie is a Marketing Specialist at Gabi. As a licensed insurance agent, she has been helping Gabi customers buy and understand auto, home, renters, landlord, and umbrella insurance in a digestible way since she joined the Gabi team in 2020. Before joining Gabi she was a globally recognized Senior Account Executive for UPS- trusted with advising top brands on how to grow and streamline their business.
Reviewed by
Robbie Boddy
Robbie is the Vice President, Head of Sales & Customer Experience at Gabi. As a licensed insurance agent, he has more than 15 years of experience in the insurance industry, joining Gabi after working with Liberty Mutual as the Assistant Vice President and Site Leader, Direct Sales and Innovation. Robbie is a member of the Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriters society and has a Master of Business Administration (MBA) from Grand Canyon University.
Read related posts
See how much you can save on your insurance today.